Nature vs Nurture

The Nature vs Nurture debate has long since captured the interest of scientists and psychologists alike. It questions whether a person’s traits, physical appearance, personality, intelligence and behaviour is tied more closely to their nature, or the way they were nurtured. Before we even begin to learn more about each side of this debate however, it’s important to understand some key terms. When discussing a person’s “nature” in this context, we often refer to their innate, biological and genetic factors. In contrast when we talk about “nurture” we describe all the environmental influences, life experiences and external factors that shape someone after birth. Because this concept has so many layers, the main focus of this article is going to be to identify how each factor affects someone’s identity through select case studies, as well as to understand why most scientists believe that ultimately it’s the interaction of both that determine who you are. The way modern theorists view the impact of nature and nurture on identity can be boiled down to the belief that life experiences (nurture) help to either reinforce or diminish an individual’s initial biological tendencies (nature).

The Diathesis-Stress model Proposes that mental, medical, and behavioural conditions stem from the interaction of a diathesis (underlying but relatively stable vulnerability) and external stressors.Thus, the natural side of this debate revolves around a diathesis, the inheritance of a specific gene that makes you more susceptible to developing a certain condition. Let’s take a look at a famous behavioural study carried out by the psychologist Avshalom Caspi in 2002 that proved how “genotypes can moderate children’s sensitivity to environmental insults”. Caspi and his team identified a gene variant that coded for an enzyme Monoamine oxidase (MAOA), that broke down neurotransmitters once they were done sending their signals. They found that low MAOA (MAOA-L) could be directly linked to higher levels of emotional intensity and impulsivity because the enzyme would take longer to break down chemical messengers, allowing them to linger longer in the brain. Alone the low-activity genotype didn’t make the male individuals tracked in this study more antisocial, but when the gene was had by boys who had experienced mistreatment, it did. These made up 12% of the study group but were twice as likely to have been diagnosed with conduct disorder in their teens, three times more likely to be convicted of a crime by the age 26, and overall committed 44% of crimes. 

Furthermore, a study held on the Dutch Famine of 1945 during the Nazi blockade in the Netherlands was able to conclude that pregnant women during that time ended up giving  birth to offspring with increased incidence of cardiovascular disease, obesity and diabetes. This is because the extreme stress the mother experienced attempting to survive rendered to the fetus as hunger which activated a “thrifty” metabolic setting that told the body to conserve energy, hold on to fat and resist insulin. 

Both case studies prove the nuance of this interplay between biological and external factors. Who we are at birth and who we become throughout life come together to make us, us. The idea that we as humans are so unique in our being, our composition, is what continues to fascinate me about science. Maybe the nature and nurture debate was never about deciding on a single root of our identity, but instead about learning to understand that we are the result of both our environment and our biological destinies.

Works Cited

National Cancer Institute. “NCI Dictionary of Genetics Terms.” National Cancer Institute (NCI), 20 July 2012, www.cancer.gov/publications/dictionaries/genetics-dictionary. Accessed 18 Nov. 2026.

Psychology Today . “Nature Vs. Nurture | Psychology Today.” Www.Psychologytoday.Com, Sussex Publishers, 2022, www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/nature-vs-nurture. Accessed 18 Nov. 2026.

Science Tech TV. The Gene Switch: How Environment Controls Your DNA | Epigenetics: Decoding Life | Full Documentary. YouTube, 18 Feb. 2025.

Stokstad, Erik. “Violent Effects of Abuse Tied to Gene.” Science, vol. 297, no. 5582, 2 Aug. 2002, pp. 752–752, science.sciencemag.org/content/297/5582/752.1, 10.1126/science.297.5582.752a. Accessed 18 Nov. 2026.

Sussman, Oliver. “Diathesis–Stress Model.” Www.Simplypsychology.Org, 14 Mar. 2022, www.simplypsychology.org/diathesis-stress-model.html. Accessed 18 Nov. 2026.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *